Pop culture, everyone knows what it is, but how many people
can actually explain why it’s so popular? There are so many things wrong with
society; popular culture includes themes like misogyny and rape culture, yet
nobody seems to see a problem with this. The lack of strong female characters
in pop culture is startling. Take, for example, the Twilight Saga, Disney
movies, Supernatural, and The Hunger games.
Bella
Swan, the Regressive Woman
Most people seem to see an issue with Twilight, just from the way it’s written, but things get even worse
the further you look into it. It’s a book written by woman, with a female
protagonist, and written for women, so you would hope that it would be at least
slightly progressive, but alas it is not.
The Twilight Saga teaches very dangerous and worrying lessons to
its readers and viewers, such as:
- Unhealthy, emotionally abusive
relationships are desirable, even wished for.
- Women’s only life choices are to
get married, have children, and be a stay-at-home mum.
- Sex is bad. Abortion is even
worse.
Bella is hardly a “strong” female character, and neither are
any of the other significant female characters in the books or movies. Think about it. Is there any important female character who
does something as progressive as having a career? Renee, Esme, Alice, Rosaline…
Nope.
Bella isn’t
independent in the slightest; she relies on Edward for everything she does, and
like the good archetypical little Mary -Jane character, she gets married and
becomes “property” of Edward.
Not All Women Are Evil
Now, I’m a huge Supernatural
fan, but even I can admit that the show has its flaws, one of the main ones
being the fact that they kill off all
of the women! I might seem like I’m overreacting, but if you look at
it, each and every one of the female characters disappears. Mary Winchester,
Jessica, Joe Harvelle, Ellen Harvelle, Ava Wilson, Bella Talbot, and many, many
other female characters have been killed off, and all that haven’t died have
disappeared due to lack of interest!
The female character that has appeared in the most ‘Supernatural’ episodes is Lisa Braeden,
Dean’s love interest, who’s been in exactly 13 episodes. 13 out of 177, that
can’t be normal.
While there
have been a fair number of female characters over the years, they’re all
remarkably similar. Usually they’re young and attractive, they rely on Sam and
Dean to save them, and they all fit in to one of four categories: mother,
daughter, love interest, evil. The only exception to this rule is Charlie, she
is the only one who isn’t sexualized, she’s the only one who is there of her
own free will, she is the only female character with a personality, how sad is
that?
The above is just two
examples, but the trope of weak female characters is alarmingly common in pop
culture. The viewing audience of Twilight and Supernatural are generally very
different which just goes to show how widespread this issue is.
So what do we do? Is it our responsibility as consumers to not watch these shows? What's about Buffy, she is pretty awesome. Slightly sexualised I'll admit but overall she could definitely be considered a good role model.
ReplyDeleteHow do you feel about Tris?